Monday, January 27, 2014
Dostoevsky.tumblr.com
Alright, so I haven't really posted in a bit (and by that I mean since, like, Friday) so there's a lot I can comment on here, which isn't really a problem because it's not like I have plot to catch up on. I don't think we can say this book is a novel or a story, unless of course we are to say that this isn't actually Dostoevsky (which I totally think it is) in which case he's writing the diary of a character he created, which I'm relatively certain is considered a fiction novel. The work leans more towards a philosophy book, but the issue with that is that Dostoevsky isn't writing down his philosophy for us, he's working through his philosophy on paper. We are reading some Russian dude think about stuff and put every word he thinks of on paper- when he constructs a long argument and quickly after contradicts his position entirely, that's not him contradicting himself, it's him changing his mind. Some people say it's confusing but I think those people are reading this like a book- it's a fucking blog; this guy is just writing- going from thought to thought getting it all on paper, we are watching the ramblings of a madman as he tries to understand the world around him. I think when he says stuff along the lines of "I was just saying that to be spiteful, I didn't mean it" (obviously he doesn't say that verbatim but he makes similar statements) that's him being aware of himself, he acknowledged that the thought he had was fueled by spite and was actually irrational, and more importantly it did not reflect his actual thinking. We are not reading something that is meant to be read as a book, in a book all statements are read as if they were true- they have to be, otherwise what kind of fucking story are you reading? We are reading a book of rambling thoughts that are subject to change just as our own thoughts and opinions are subject to change. This is not a man writing a story, it's a blogger having an existential crisis- or perhaps just a philosophical one.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Blog Archive
-
▼
2014
(325)
-
▼
January
(123)
- discussion post 2
- My First Class Discussion
- Happiness
- Discussion Post Two
- Discussion Part 2 (Alexia Barrios)
- Today's Discussions
- The Touchy Subject of Population Control (Zane Man...
- Selfishness
- The selfishness of humanity
- Second Thoughts on Today's Discussion
- The Divine vs Reality
- Class Discussion (1/30/14) (Meagan Adler)
- Discussion: 1/30
- 2nd Class Discussion
- Discussion part 1
- Comment on Carlye's post
- Discussion Number One
- Comment to Everyone Else' s Thoughts - I was absen...
- Comment on First Two Pages, The Painful Presence o...
- Discussion Part 1 (Alexia Barrios)
- First Day
- First discussion
- Discussion: 1/29
- Pain
- Setting the Tone (Zane Mandell)
- The thought of himself
- 1st Discussion (Carlye Nealon)
- The Bullied to the Bullier
- Class Discussion (1/29/14) (Meagan Adler)
- never mind..i hate him
- Part 6: The End (Alexia Barrios)
- Ending
- Post 6
- 6
- Reaction Number Six
- “I am alone and they are everyone” (31) (Zane Mand...
- Liza
- Post 6
- How frustrating
- The End
- The Ending (Carlye Nealon)
- Finishing Off
- The Human Condition, As Described by An Outside Party
- Looking at Myself
- “I conquered myself” (Meagan Adler)
- I understand him
- He speaks the truth
- Favorite quote
- Post four
- Silence (Zane Mandell)
- 1/27/2014 post
- Part 5: "...most awful moments of my life" (Alexi...
- Concept of Love (Carlye Nealon)
- Allusions and Contradictions
- Post 5
- Parallels with Raskolnikov
- Notes From The Underground Part Five
- A Coward
- Almost Done
- Dostoevsky.tumblr.com
- Appearances
- Projection
- “They (the lovers) are their own judges. Love is ...
- sympathy
- Liar Liar
- post 4
- Notes From the Underground Part Four
- Who is the man who has found his corner? (Zane Man...
- Post 4
- Mental Defect?
- Post four
- Part 4: "A tyrant at heart" (Alexia Barrios)
- Fourth Reading
- DOES HE NOT GET THE HINT (Carlye Nealon)
- Dostoyevsky...
- A Hard Life
- Why the lies?
- “Owing to its rarity, perhaps, any external event,...
- Genius versus idiot
- Past versus present
- In Your Own Head (Zane Mandell)
- Answers
- third post
- Post 3
- The Issues of Self-Awareness in Dostoyevsky's Works
- Post #3
- Part 3: A Man in Hiding (Alexia Barrios)
- Part 2 (Carlye Nealon)
- Notes form the Underground Part 3
- Call Me Crazy
- Betrayed
- “I never have been a coward at heart, though I hav...
- Wary Reading
- The ideas intertwine and become more complex
- Second Impression
- Notes from the Underground Part Two
- The truth
- Going Underground (Zane Mandell)
- "Perhaps I really regard myself as an intelligent ...
- This book just keeps getting better
-
▼
January
(123)
No comments:
Post a Comment